Swing Trading: Rules and Philosophy - Traders Log (2024)

By Linda Bradford Raschke

My style is based on the “Taylor Trading Technique”, a short-term method for trading daily price movements that relies entirely on odds and percentages . It is a method as opposed to a system. Very few people can blindly follow a system, though many find it easier to be discretionary in a systematic way.

Because this short-term swing technique generates frequent trades, it is important to know the “correct plays,” to lock in profits, and to seek the “true trend.” Taking a loss is merely playing for better position. One trades strictly for probable future results, not for what the market might do.

To know the “correct play” is to know whether to buy or sell first, to exit or hold. Trades are based on “objective points,” which are simply the previous day’s high and low. Movement between these two points determines the “true trend.”

When swing trading, adjust your expectations. The lower your expectations, the happier you will be and, ironically, the more money you will probably make! Entries are a piece of cake, but you must also trust yourself to get out of bad situations and trades. It is important to use tighter stops when trading swings and wider stops when trading trends.

This method teaches you to anticipate! Never react! Know what you are going to do before the market opens. Always have a plan–but be flexible! “See” your stop (support or resistance) before initiating a trade. Know how to trade out of trouble situations and get off the hook with the smallest possible loss.

Finally, never trade in narrow, dead markets. The swings are too small. Never chase a market. Rather than worry that you’ve missed a move, think instead, “Oh, boy! I’ve got oscillations and volatility back…”

Swing Trading: Rules and Philosophy - Traders Log (2)

Basic Rules for Swing Traders

But first–the rules! Because of the short-term nature of this technique, swing traders must adhere to some very basic rules, including:

But first–the rules! Because of the short-term nature of this technique, swing traders must adhere to some very basic rules, including:

  • If the trade moves in your favor, carry it overnight–the odds favor follow-through. Expect to exit the next day around the objective point. An overnight gap presents an excellent opportunity to take profits. Concentrating on only one entry or one exit per day relieves the pressure.
  • If your entry is correct, the market should move favorably almost immediately. It may come back to test and/or exceed your entry point a little, but that’s OK.
  • Do not carry a losing position overnight. Exit and play for better position the next day.
  • A strong close indicates a strong opening the following day.
  • If the market doesn’t perform as expected, exit on the first reaction.
  • If the market offers you a windfall of big profits, take them to the bank on the close.
  • If you are long and the market closes flat, indicating a lower opening the following day, scratch or exit the trade. Play for better position the next day.
  • It is always OK to scratch a trade!
  • Use tight stops when swing trading (wider stops when trading trend).
  • The goal always is to minimize risk and create “Freebies.”
  • When in doubt–get out! You have lost your road map and your game plan!
  • Place your orders at the market.
  • When the trade isn’t working, exit on the first reaction.
  • ANTICIPATE!

“Trading the Swing”

How does one anticipate entry? The following may be indicators of a buy day or a sell day:

Classic Trading Cycle
Swing Trading: Rules and Philosophy - Traders Log (4)
Swing Trading: Rules and Philosophy - Traders Log (5)
Swing Trading: Rules and Philosophy - Traders Log (6)
Swing Trading: Rules and Philosophy - Traders Log (7)

The Count

Start searching for a buying day 2 days after a swing high or, conversely, a shorting day 2 days after a swing low. Ideally, the market will move in complete 5-day cycles. (In a strong trend, the market will move 4 days in the primary direction and only 1 in reaction. Thus, one must seek entry 1 day earlier.)

“Check Mark” on the Test

The potential entry is sought opposite, or contrary to, the previous day’s close. If looking to buy (sell), one first wants the market to “test” the previous day’s low (high), preferably early in the day, and then form a trading pattern that looks like a “check mark” (see examples).

This pattern sets up and establishes a “double stop point” or strong support. If entering a market with only a “single stop point” or support formed by today’s low only, exit on the same day–the trade is clearly against the trend.

Close vs. Open

The close should indicate the following day’s opening. When a market opens opposite what is expected or indicated by the trend, one may first look to “fade” it–but must take profits quickly. Then look to reverse!

Support (Resistance)

Is today’s support (resistance) higher or lower than yesterday’s?

Swing Measurements

Where is the market relative to the last swing high or low? Look for swings (up or down) of equal length, and for retracements of equal percentage.

Additional Considerations!

No matter in what time frame, always look for supply at tops and support at bottoms. Penetrations should be accompanied by volume and activity.

Expect trends, either up or down, to last for either 2 or 4 weeks.

The following conditions are fairly reliable indicators for the start of one of these trends (I personally skip the first buy or sell swing when one occurs because the move ensuing could be quite strong):

  • Narrowest range in the last 7 days
  • 3 consecutive days with small range
  • The point of a wedge
  • A breakaway gap
  • A rising ADX (14-period) above 32

Practice

Because a certain amount of confidence in any technique is required to trade it consistently, paper trading can cultivate the faith necessary to recognize and trade pattern repetition. Although the temptation to try too many different styles and patterns always exists, one must strive ultimately to trade in just one consistent manner–or at least to integrate techniques into your own unique philosophy.

System Characteristics

Certain points about trading short-term swings deserve note. Understanding the nature of short-term systems can help you recognize the psychological aspect of trading.

When consistently following a short-term system, you should expect a very high win/loss ratio. Though the objectives with this style of swing trading appear conservative, you will almost always incur “positive slippage”.

In all systems, winners are skewed. Even though making steady profits, 3-4 really big trades may actually make the month. It is vitally important to always “lock in” your trades. Don’t give back profits when short-term trading.

You may be astonished at just how big some winners may be from catching the swings “just right!”

Decision-Making

I feel it is important to address this topic. Every time you make a trade, you make a decision. The more decisions you make, the more you increase your self-esteem.

You grow with each decision, yet each decision has a price–you must discard a choice, and you must commit. Conditions are always imperfect! You must allow yourself to fail. Allow for human limitations and incorrect choices. Reserve compassion for yourself and your limitations.

There is so much instantaneous information available to all market players today. It is OK to use intuition and to listen to that little voice inside your head, “Does the trade feel right?” If in doubt, get out…!

Golden Rules

Finally, I want to leave you with what I believe are two Golden Rules, applicable to all traders but, of essential importance to short-term swing traders:

  • NEVER, ever, average a loss! Sell out if you think you are wrong. Buy back when you believe you are right.
  • NEVER, NEVER, NEVER listen to anyone else’s opinion! Only YOU know when your trade isn’t working.

Recommended reading list

  • The TAYLOR Trading Technique, by George Douglass Taylor, 1950
  • Trading is a Business, by Joe Ross
  • Day Trading with Short-term Price Patterns & Opening Range Breakout, by Toby Crabel
  • Forecasting Financial Markets (or Technical Analysis Explained), by Tony Plummer
  • The ABC of Stock Speculation, by A. Nelson, 1903
Swing Trading: Rules and Philosophy - Traders Log (2024)

FAQs

What is the 1% rule in swing trading? ›

The 1% rule is a key risk management strategy for swing traders, where a trader aims to limit each loss to 1% of their portfolio's value. traders have enough capital to keep trading and avoid significant losses that could wipe out their account.

What is the golden rule of swing trading? ›

Finally, I want to leave you with what I believe are two Golden Rules, applicable to all traders but, of essential importance to short-term swing traders: NEVER, ever, average a loss! Sell out if you think you are wrong. Buy back when you believe you are right.

What is the failure rate of swing traders? ›

However, it's important to note that an estimated 90% of swing traders do not make money. This suggests that the average success rate of swing traders who do earn a profit annually is about 10%.

What is a realistic profit from swing trading? ›

The Swing Trading strategy can lead to profits in the short term, usually in the range of 10% to 30%. However, as most things investing usually are, it is a risky bet. About 90% of traders report losses during trading.

Can you swing trade with $1000 dollars? ›

That's why it's tough to put a dollar amount on what is considered a “small account”. However, we see many new traders start small with just $1,000 in their accounts. This is a pretty good starting place for new traders because your risk is pretty limited.

What is the best swing trade strategy? ›

Five strategies for swing trading stocks
  • Fibonacci retracements. The Fibonacci retracement pattern can be used to help traders identify support and resistance levels, and therefore possible reversal levels on stock charts. ...
  • Support and resistance triggers. ...
  • Channel trading. ...
  • 10- and 20-day SMA. ...
  • MACD crossover.

What is the best pattern for swing trading? ›

The ascending triangle pattern is a chart formation that's produced when price movements form an “L” shape. This signals that the buyers are in control and the stock is likely to swing up – making it one of the best swing trading chart patterns for predicting bullish reversals.

What are the common swing trading mistakes? ›

Don't have a trading plan (every trade is a mistake). Wrong position size or don't have a position sizing method. Taking too many correlated positions (increases risk…as the correlated trades are essentially the same). Got out of a position before the planned exit.

Who is the most successful swing trader? ›

Paul Tudor Jones - Another famous swing trader is Paul Tudor Jones. Jones is a billionaire hedge fund manager who is known for his aggressive trading style. He is one of the most successful traders of all time, and he has a net worth of over $5 billion.

Why does swing trading not work? ›

Swing trade positions are subject to overnight and weekend market risk. Abrupt market reversals can result in substantial losses. Swing traders often miss longer-term trends in favor of short-term market moves.

How many people make a living swing trading? ›

We've seen estimations that as many as 90% of swing traders fail to make money in the stock market – meaning they either break even or lose money. That suggests that the average swing trading success rate is somewhere around 10% – meaning 10% of swing traders actually bring in profit over the course of a year.

How long should you hold a swing trade? ›

The holding period for a typical swing trade falls somewhere between two days and two weeks. Of course, there are exceptions where some trades are held for longer periods of time – but we'll talk about that later on. For now, let's focus on the average holding period for a swing trade.

Can you live off swing trading? ›

Can you make a living swing trading, or is this just another case of “too good to be true”? This trading style is positioned between day trading and long-term investment and demands a strategic approach and a solid understanding of market trends. But, yes – you can absolutely get started swing trading for a living.

What is the best timeframe for swing trading? ›

The best time frame for swing trading if you have just started investing is between 6 months to 1 year. Technical analysis is the tool that is often used to select a stock and perform trades. The analysis of stocks gives you an insight into when to buy the stock and when to go short on the stock.

What is the average income of a swing trader? ›

The average salary for a Swing trader is ₹1,00,000 in New Delhi, India.

What is the 2 1 trading rule? ›

A positive reward:risk ratio such as 2:1 would dictate that your potential profit is larger than any potential loss, meaning that even if you suffer a losing trade, you only need one winning trade to make you a net profit.

What is the 3 1 rule in trading? ›

To increase your chances of profitability, you want to trade when you have the potential to make 3 times more than you are risking. If you give yourself a 3:1 reward-to-risk ratio, you have a significantly greater chance of ending up profitable in the long run.

What is No 1 rule of trading? ›

Rule 1: Always Use a Trading Plan

You need a trading plan because it can assist you with making coherent trading decisions and define the boundaries of your optimal trade. A decent trading plan will assist you with avoiding making passionate decisions without giving it much thought.

What is the key to swing trading? ›

Swing trading strategies can be aided by using candlestick charts and oscillators to identify potential trades. Oscillators track momentum and help identify reversals when they begin to diverge from the existing trend.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rubie Ullrich

Last Updated:

Views: 6242

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rubie Ullrich

Birthday: 1998-02-02

Address: 743 Stoltenberg Center, Genovevaville, NJ 59925-3119

Phone: +2202978377583

Job: Administration Engineer

Hobby: Surfing, Sailing, Listening to music, Web surfing, Kitesurfing, Geocaching, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Rubie Ullrich, I am a enthusiastic, perfect, tender, vivacious, talented, famous, delightful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.