Kurt Warner's Pro Football Hall of Fame credentials questioned, defended after post (2024)

jeremy cluff, arizona republic

·5 min read

Kurt Warner was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2017 after a 12-year career that saw him take two teams to Super Bowl appearances.

He went 67-49 as a starter in his career, and completed 2,666 of his 4,070 pass attempts, throwing for 208 touchdowns, with 128 passes intercepted.

But one writer is now wondering if Warner should have been inducted into the Hall of Fame.

Jeff Pearlman, a former sports writer for Sports Illustrated and author, questioned Warner's Hall of Fame credentials with a recent Twitter post.

His post simply showed Warner's career stats with the question: "How is Kurt Warner in the Hall?"

More: Antonio Brown landing spots: Arizona Cardinals listed as potential next team for receiver

More: Reaction: Kurt Warner makes Pro Football Hall of Fame

More: Kurt Warner outlines why he thinks Arizona Cardinals can make Super Bowl

How is Kurt Warner in the Hall? pic.twitter.com/yiWHmts0kU

— Jeff Pearlman (@jeffpearlman) January 6, 2022

The post set off a firestorm of replies, with many people defending Warner's Hall inclusion.

Here are some of the replies:

Multiple MVPs, Super Bowl MVP, 3 super bowl appearances with all 3 the most prolific passes performances in the game’s history (until Brady’s last few), dozens of reg season records that stand today, can’t tell story of NFL without him. I could go on.

— Rich Eisen (@richeisen) January 6, 2022

At the time he retired, the Rams as an organization had been to 3 total Super Bowls…Kurt was the QB for 2 of them

Arizona had only been to one SB
And Kurt was the QB of that one too

Two organizations
Four total Super Bowls
And Kurt was the starting QB of 3 of them

That’s why

— Jackson Kruger (@JacksonRKruger) January 6, 2022

By being clearly qualified!

— Mike Tanier (@MikeTanier) January 6, 2022

Once you've had BOTH a regular season MVP AND a Super Bowl MVP it's really hard to deny you the Hall of Fame. Kurt Warner had that in his first year as a starter. He then had another regular season MVP, led two more teams to Super Bowls and was chosen to three more Pro Bowls.

— Michael David Smith (@MichaelDavSmith) January 6, 2022

Is it the lack of counting stats that is what Jeff has an issue with? @kurt13warner started his playing career at age 28.. so yeah, they'll be lacking a bit there. It's a good showing of doing the most of the time you do have.

— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) January 6, 2022

Took two moribund franchises to the Super Bowl, winning one; piled up gaudy stats despite making his first start at 28; led arguably the most memorable NFL offense in the last 40 years; revived his career in Arizona in his mid-30s. He deserves to be there.

— Pete Croatto (@PeteCroatto) January 6, 2022

Any QB that gets the Cardinals to the Superbowl goes in the hall.

— JLh (@Hutcja) January 6, 2022

1 of 9 players ever with 2 MVPs, 1 of 2 players ever to make it to the Super Bowl with 3 different head coaches, won a Super Bowl & was the games MVP, led the league in multiple of the most important passing statistics multiple years. He is incredibly deserving of a gold jacket

— Grant Gossling (@goose_32) January 6, 2022

Some people also questioned Warner's Hall of Fame qualifications:

I have said for years it does not make sense to me. He had 2 great years with the rams and 2 good years with the cardinals, that’s it. And speaking of the rams, he had 4 hall of famers on his offense outside of him. And with the the cardinals he had 3. I just don’t get it

— Stephen Hemming (@CoachHemming) January 6, 2022

Two elite years and a great story does not a HOF QB make.

— Drewski (@AMurawa) January 6, 2022

He was definitely good but I’ve been saying for years he is overrated at least in terms of all time opinion of him. Trent Green who was also pretty good put up roughly the same DVOA when Warner was out and Warner never came close to his production from 99-01 in a super offense.

— Stat Magician (@StatMagician) January 6, 2022

He should be no where near the Hall. 4-5 good seasons.

— Kyle (@Kmarden8590) January 6, 2022

Warner also responded to the tweet, saying that he was "going 2 keep the jacket, if that's cool!"

Haha, those ?s we ask that have multiple answers & those answers depend on lens u are looking through while answering! I have some thoughts, I understand both sides & I’ll be in back of the room while u debate, bc whatever the answer I’m going 2 keep the jacket, if that’s cool! https://t.co/evewHkJEzU

— Kurt Warner (@kurt13warner) January 6, 2022

Not getting anyone - I’m just stating facts… I’ve asked myself the same question & have come up with multiple answers…

— Kurt Warner (@kurt13warner) January 6, 2022

Do you think Kurt Warner is a Hall of Famer?

VOTE: Does Kurt Warner belong in Pro Football Hall of Fame? @azcentral #RedSea (Debate: https://t.co/xdrg3OYZbi) Y=Yes, N=No

— azcentral sports (@azcsports) January 6, 2022

NFL Week 18 picks, predictions:

Reach Jeremy Cluff at jeremy.cluff@arizonarepublic.com. Follow him on Twitter @Jeremy_Cluff.

Support local journalism: Subscribe to azcentral.com today.

This article originally appeared on Arizona Republic: Kurt Warner Pro Football Hall of Fame credentials questioned, defended

Kurt Warner's Pro Football Hall of Fame credentials questioned, defended after post (2024)

FAQs

How much older is Brenda Warner than Kurt? ›

She was four years his senior, and the then-21-year-old Kurt was a student at the University of Northern Iowa, where he played quarterback and harbored dreams of playing in the NFL.

Has an undrafted QB ever won a Super Bowl? ›

Warner helped lead the Rams to a championship, defeating the Tennessee Titans in Super Bowl XXXIV. In the victory, he threw two touchdowns and had 414 passing yards, a record at the time. He is the only undrafted quarterback to win a Super Bowl, the only undrafted player to be named NFL MVP and Super Bowl MVP.

Why did the Packers cut Kurt Warner? ›

Unaware of the meaning of the term, she shortly thereafter learned the fate of most “camp arms.” The Packers, with quarterbacks BRETT FAVRE,(Opens in a new window) Mark Brunell and Ty Detmer also participating in that camp, cut Kurt from the team. “He wasn't ready. He wasn't recruited out of high school.

Did Kurt Warner get in the Hall of Fame? ›

He was also the first quarterback to win a Super Bowl during his first season as the primary starter. Warner was inducted to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2017, and is the first and only player inducted to both the Pro Football Hall of Fame and the Arena Football Hall of Fame.

Where does Kurt Warner rank all time? ›

All-Time Passer Rating
1Aaron Rodgers104.93
8Kurt Warner93.71
9Ben Roethlisberger92.69
10Joe Montana*92.26
11Matt Schaub91.92
159 more rows

How long did Brenda and Kurt Warner date? ›

She was everything he needed. Brenda Warner will admit it took the stout St. Louis Rams quarterback some time to get up the nerve to propose. They dated for five years, but she said it was time they needed to grow individually, and to push each other toward excellence.

Did Kurt Warner adopt all his children? ›

Warner adopted Brenda's two children, son Zachary and daughter Jesse, after their marriage. Zachary is blind from the head injuries he got when he was accidentally dropped by his birth-father as a baby.

Why did Kurt Warner not start in college? ›

Unable to land a football scholarship to a Division I-A (now known as Football Bowl Subdivision) college, Warner attended the University of Northern Iowa, where he did not become a starter until his fifth and final year.

Why did Kurt Warner retire? ›

"Coming to practice every day, believing you're the best player and never getting the chance to play, running scout team after being in the league and winning MVPs and going to Super Bowls, it was mentally exhausting," Warner said. "That's why retirement came to mind. "That was the most frustrating part of my career."

Was Kurt Warner undrafted? ›

Warner was undrafted in 1994 out of Northern Iowa, as the Packers gave him a shot to make a roster with Brett Favre, Mark Brunell, and Ty Detmer. After not making the Packers, Warner went from stocking shelves to shining with the Iowa Barnstormers in the Arena Football League.

How many Super Bowls did Kurt Warner go to? ›

Kurt Warner had 3 games played in Super Bowls in his career.
NAMEDATEROUND
Kurt Warner1/30/2000Super Bowl
Kurt Warner2/3/2002Super Bowl
Kurt Warner2/1/2009Super Bowl

How rich is Kurt Warner? ›

Kurt Warner has an estimated net worth of $30 million. He earned most of his wealth from his football career, which spanned over two decades. During that time, he played for teams like the St. Louis Rams and Arizona Cardinals and in NFL Europe and Arena Football League.

How old was Kurt Warner's wife when they met? ›

Kurt was a struggling 21-year-old quarterback at the University of Northern Iowa who, he says, "sat on the bench for four years" as his NFL dreams seemed to be fading by the day. Brenda, then 25, was a newly-divorced single mom of two working her way through nursing school.

How old was Kurt Warner when he retired? ›

Warner played in the NFL for 12 seasons before announcing his retirement at the age of 38 in January 2010.

Does Kurt Warner have a blind son? ›

Their oldest son, Zachary, whom Kurt adopted along with Brenda's oldest daughter Jesse, has been blind since suffering a head injury in an accident when he was a baby. They have seven children, three boys and four girls.

Why wasn't Kurt Warner drafted? ›

Warner was seen as more of a training camp arm than a player who had a real chance to make the team, especially with Brett Favre and Mark Brunell already on the roster as quarterbacks. Warner didn't make the team.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated:

Views: 6228

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.